The following is a speech I delivered on 2.2.15 as part of the Lowell House Speech Series; in it, I take viewers behind the scenes of how With a Terrible Fate came to be.

I offer the transcript below, in full:

I came to college last year with a plan: to follow the pre-med track, study chemistry and biology, and become a doctor.  I liked psychology and wanted to help people, and I assumed that psychiatry was a good career path for me.  I knew where I was going.  

Have you ever felt that way?

I also love video games.  So it came to pass that I broke up Life Sciences 1a problem sets by turning on my Nintendo 3DS and immersing myself in the stories of games spanning entire universes.  In “Kingdom Hearts,” I embarked on a journey to restore light to a world shrouded in darkness. Then, I put my hobby away and returned to arrow-pushing diagrams of chemical reactions.  Now, in my sophomore year, my plan has changed. I am a philosophy concentrator.  I study stories instead of chemicals.  

How did this happen to me?

In the third grade, my parents gave me my first gaming console and a collection of games from the “Legend of Zelda” series.  I turned on my television set and began to discover the story called “Ocarina of Time,” an epic which invited me into a world beyond my own, and which depended on me in order to exist. I marveled at this bizarre device that allowed me to be told a story, and – at the same time – to tell one. Before my eyes, the character I controlled – Link – was thrust from childhood into adulthood to slay the Great King of Evil, Ganondorf.  But surely, this was child’s play – these were just games, not the literature taught in school.

At school, I found theater: a middle ground between games and novels.  As an actor on the stage, I transformed myself into part of a story – Banquo in his dying moments in “Macbeth”; the priest on trial in “Doubt.”  Of course, unlike video games, I could not be the audience and the actor at the same time; but theater has been accepted into the academic canon.  I went to school, read, acted, directed, and wrote plays; but, late at night, I devoured video games.

As I have grown and played more games, I have found that their stories have shaped much of my philosophy.  In “Ocarina of Time,” that game I discovered in elementary school, Link is sent seven years into the future so that he might be mature enough to fulfill his destiny as a hero.  After the Sage who sent him through time explains to Link that he must defeat the world’s greatest villain, he asks Link:  “Do you understand your destiny?”  The player is given a choice to answer either “yes” or “no”; answer “no,” and the Sage will repeat what Link must do and then ask the same question, until Link answers “yes,” and is then allowed to proceed.  When I reflect now on the path that led me to philosophy and video games, I understand it as a shift between two different interpretations of Link’s choice.

Interpretation Number One:  life has a particular path for you, and you must accept the path in order to proceed.  On this interpretation, the capacity to reject your destiny is superficial.  The domain of what I could “do,” for a long time, was limited to the canon of what was taught:  I could pick a “serious academic interest” only from the fields in which academia was already seriously interested, and develop as though following a pre-determined script.  Medicine was my choice from that script.

But there is also Interpretation Number Two:  the script cannot proceed, and the story cannot exist, without the player.  The player can reject the script as many different times and ways as he wishes before he chooses to proceed; even though the script still exists, this interpretation describes a script which cedes authority to the player.             

Through Interpretation Number Two, I learned to transform the path of my story and academic career.  In my senior year of high school, I replaced one of my standard courses with a course on video games.  Now, I am working with a professor in the philosophy department to study how video games tell stories.  Right now, we’re looking at how player involvement in the “Legend of Zelda” differentiates its world from the magical realism of Jorge Luis Borges.  What I have learned since coming to college is that value and meaning depend on the choice to take your own passions seriously; that is what I seek to do in understanding my destiny.

 

 


Avatar photo

Aaron Suduiko

Aaron Suduiko is the Founder and Chief Video Game Analyst of With a Terrible Fate. In his capacity as a philosopher of video-game storytelling, he specializes in the relationship between player and avatar, and the myriad ways in which that relationship centrally influences the stories of video games. The heart of Suduiko's philosophy of video-game fiction is his theory of "the fictional player": according to this view, the player's role in a video game is not that of identification with the game's avatar; instead, the player plays a separate, more metaphysically foundational fictional role that makes possible events within a video game's story actual, similar to Leibniz's conception of god. Suduiko's application of this view in his analyses on With a Terrible Fate have led to novel interpretations of games such as Bloodborne, Dark Souls, Dishonored, NieR, Returnal, Xenoblade Chronicles, Bandai Namco's "Tales of" series, BioShock Infinite, Code Vein, Final Fantasy VII Remake, Ni No Kuni, and Silent Hill. The foundations of the fictional player theory may be found in the Journal of the Philosophy of Games: https://journals.uio.no/JPG/article/view/4799/5504 Suduiko graduated Harvard College in 2017 with high honors in his major, philosophy. Part of his degree included three independent studies on the storytelling of video games, advised by philosophy professors. In his senior year, he wrote an honors thesis on the ontology of video games as a storytelling object, earning high honors for the written work and highest honors for his oral defense of it. Suduiko has shared his work on the philosophy of video-game storytelling at a variety of venues, including: Harvard’s philosophy department; PAX West, PAX East, PAX South, and PAX Aus; Harvard’s annual ARTS FIRST festival; the British Society of Aesthetics’ postgraduate conference; and SUNY Oneonta’s undergraduate philosophy conference. An article adapted from a chapter of his thesis on the ontology of video-game storytelling was published in the peer-reviewed Journal of the Philosophy of Games. His work on the aesthetics of quantum mechanics in BioShock Infinite was published in Cornell’s undergraduate philosophy journal, Logos. He’s advised Harvard librarians about the literary value of video games and the need to make them available as library resources. Suduiko started analyzing video games in his senior year of high school, when he compared and contrasted the role-playing dynamics of video games and stage plays. After he started his degree in philosophy in 2014 and heard about the 3D remake of Majora’s Mask, he created With a Terrible Fate as a personal blog analyzing the philosophical and artistic value of Majora’s Mask. Since then, he’s grown With a Terrible Fate into a publication of video game analysts striving to understand the stories of video games in new, rigorous, illuminating ways. Suduiko is currently pursuing a PhD in philosophy at the University of Southern California. Beyond the direct analysis of video-game stories, his main research interests center on how the structure and dynamics of video-game stories can serve as novel models for illuminating real-world issues of practical reasoning, social context, and personal identity.

0 Comments

Leave a Reply

Avatar placeholder

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *